by blankinput » Thu Jul 17, 2014 9:20 pm
@rjbman
I listened to this band way back in like 2001 and it took me until last year to actually sit down and methodically comb through their discography. I listened to The Fragile for a month straight October -> November 2013, every single day, and still think it's one of the more interesting albums I've downloaded in the past five years. Extremely dense and his classical background is painfully obvious on it.
Start with Pretty Hate Machine, go up to and including The Fragile. It's a near tie between The Downward Spiral and The Fragile, though compositionally The Fragile is far more mature; no real question. The Downward Spiral is supremely pissed, so it's good for that, and the production is amazing for what it sets out to achieve.
The band is mostly irrelevant at this point and Trent Reznor is insane, but The Slip was cool. I think Trent succeeds in putting himself in the music mores than his contemporaries, and his decline as a human being is really palpable from Pretty Hate Machine (innocent with pop sensibilities) to The Fragile (repentant and sad).