by rublev » Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:47 am
frustratingly i think the centre left are generally in identity crisis mode all over europe because they're struggling to find exactly where they now sit in relation to state / labour / free movement etc. the difficultly with syriza as a test case is that what happened there was so specific and 'never seen before' - in broad terms they were offering something they couldn't really deliver (not surprising for insurgent populist parties). perhaps in greece the story is less syriza and more pasok - the social democratic party that was 'the left' for decades until the crash and have now simply evaporated. there are a few exceptions in coalitions across the continent i guess, but most centre left have seen support leak away (just look at front national, 5 star movement, freedom party, party for freedom, podemos, green etc). simple left/right divide seems pretty precarious. most of our economies have had fundamental shifts in how they're arranged (manufacturing to majority services etc) and a lot of the original areas of centre leftism have been co-opted by the broader political spectrum (even UKIP). i think the referendum highlighted quite quickly the divide in 'identity' on the left too - a cosmopolitan liberal london vs. larger cities in the north and pretty much anywhere else that has previously voted labour. the addition of scotland makes it even more confusing. mixed demographics, lots of ex-industry, ex-labour heartland (labour are now finished and i see no way back), but clearly identifying different 'left' principles.
UK labour seems to represent many centre left parties throughout europe in that that they're struggling to hone in on what they're doing, who they represent, why they WANT to represent, and how to get there. i'm not a londoner but i like sadiq khan and his pragmatism, and my impression is he has broad appeal - maybe all this isn't manageable within labour, who knows (of course mayor is v different). i'm neither french nor italian but in france, in italy etc, seem to be trying to dig out new distinctive centre left answers to eurozone problems, which i guess is encouraging (but i'm aware they're controversial characters, macron and labour reform especially, and may be seen as not addressing 'traditional left' issues).
tl;dr... dunno mate, wish my lib dem vote mattered once in a while (edit: actually, need to think about that more... maybe mean more in the sense of a credible left alternative / opposition that pressured both lab and con to be less repellent and more open minded)