Damn
teck, this is something I was stressing about for months before I picked up my Red Wings. I'm still looking at possibly picking up more. The main other boot I was looking at was the Palladium Pampa Tactical:
Good product video here:
I like the mix of leather/rubber/nylon, tread, and zipper, but I worry about the shape of the top of the foot/toe area and the zipper quality. They're cheapest off of Amazon, going for ~70-80 USD.
I did a lot of research into Corcorans but everything said the quality was shoddy (leather & hardware) and the Munson last is pretty ugly in the toebox. Other than those, I was never able to find a good $100-200 combat, which is why I picked up my RWs when they went on sale down to $150.
The internet seems to like Docs as far as I can tell. To me they fall into the same kind of pseudo-authentic-cool realm as Air Force 1's and Timberlands, in the sense that people recognize them as signifiers of much larger cultural movements or ideas. I've actually liked the patent black Docs every time I've seen them worn, I just have no idea how I would wear them. They'd probably be a lot of fun to fuck up.